Mckellar Confectionery in Thunder Bay is a beloved gem for hamburger enthusiasts, known for its old-school charm and nostalgic service. Nestled at 241 McKellar St S, this place has perfected the art of creating flavorful burgers and coney dogs that stand the test of time. Reviews from loyal patrons highlight the remarkable efficiency of the kitchen, with one customer, Marty S, praising how much food they produce with minimal equipment. The coney dogs here receive special acclaim, with Carrie Williamson declaring them unmatched after a 25-year search for the perfect bite. The unique coney sauce is a delightful discovery for many, like Kayla, who found it not only delicious but also affordably priced. Regulars like Jim Lanigan cherish the consistency of recipes that have remained unchanged for decades, coupled with friendly service from the staff, including the spirited Maria. Returning customers like Kristian Hald reminisce fondly about the flavors they've missed, demonstrating Mckellar's ability to evoke nostalgia through food. Every visit promises the same delectable offering, making it a must-stop whenever in Thunder Bay. For comfort food lovers, Mckellar Confectionery delivers on its promise of classic taste and community feel, ensuring every bite is filled with warm memories.
Amenities and More
Accessibility
No wheelchair-accessible entrance
No wheelchair-accessible seating
Service options
Offers delivery
Offers takeaway
Serves dine-in
Popular for
Popular for lunch
Popular for dinner
Good for solo dining
Offerings
Serves coffee
Serves food
Quick bite
Dining options
Serves lunch
Serves dinner
Amenities
Has toilet
Atmosphere
Casual
Historic
Crowd
Good for groups
Popular with tourists
Popular with university students
Planning
Doesn't accept reservations
Payments
Accepts debit cards
Accepts NFC mobile payments
Credit cards
Children
Good for kids
Parking
Free of charge street parking
Free parking lot
Photos
Reviews For Mckellar Confectionery
Marty S
May 5,2025
For such an old relic they have their product, system and service down to a science. I can’t believe how much food they get out with as little equipment as they have. Super nice people and great service. If you’re looking for value, old school burgers and dogs, this is the place. Bravo!
Carrie Williamson
Apr 30,2025
No other coney dogs compare, by far the best I’ve had in 25 years!!!!
Kayla
Apr 30,2025
I had to try this burger when a local friend recommended the place and was pleasantly surprised! I had no idea what coney sauce was, and I don't think we have it anywhere back in Winnipeg, but it was delicious and also reasonably priced! Whenever I come through Thunder Bay in the future I will be making sure to drop in again.
Jim Lanigan
Apr 21,2025
I've been coming here for years, the coney sauce is undeniably unmatched. I could sit here and eat cheeseburgers all day and still crave them. I live out in Alberta but as soon as I'm in town I come and see Maria and pig out on the burgers lol. The staff is amazing, so friendly. I love the fact that the menu and the recipes remain unchanged for decades. Love coming here! I always will return here
kristian Hald
Apr 2,2025
The food and service was amazing. I don’t live in town anymore, everything was just as I remembered. Will be back the next visit.
Chrissy Greaves
Mar 2,2025
I moved away from Thunder Bay almost 20 years ago and I lived off of their Coney burgers. I came back from Saskatchewan for an unexpected unplanned trip. Went back twice this time around. I had to have my Coney burgers. They are the best burgers I've ever had.
Kimberly Vaillancourt
Feb 25,2025
Always worth a stop ..... Always get the same thing (hamburger with sauce and onions)
Niall McKee
Feb 22,2025
This is BY Far the best Coney in town. it has a spice/flavor to it that isn't over powerfully yelling onion. Also they seem to be using a 5 star bun that doesn't get hard after they cool down from the steaming. Fries are great hot. Highly recommended stop in. Don't bother with the parking lot though always hard to get in and out of. Just park on McKellar St.
Reviews For Mckellar Confectionery